Josh Pennell was only 26 when he bought his first property asset in 2008. While he had a decade of experience as a financial advisor and investing in shares, the world of purchasing property in Australia was new. It was the biggest, riskiest commitment he’d ever made.
This story takes a direct look at the challenges and incredible rewards of pivoting an investment to a short-term holiday rental. Josh provides candid advice on managing a busy Airbnb from afar, the crucial amenities that increase yield, and the core principles of land value and market timing that underpin any successful investment—especially one intended for the lucrative but demanding holiday market. You’ll learn his core lessons on timing, land value, and the strategic use of debt to build wealth.
The remote reality: Why airbnb management is a nightmare
Josh’s journey took a detour when he moved regionally and converted one of his assets into an Airbnb. While the yield potential was excellent, he found out quickly that remote management is a nightmare. This section focuses on the pitfalls and how to set up an investment for success in the short-term letting space.
Key takeaways for short-term letting
If you’re considering an Airbnb when purchasing property in australia, focus on accessibility and amenity to balance the inevitable stress:
• Distance is Stress: Managing a holiday rental from seven hours away led to extreme stress, issues with cleaning, and constant maintenance calls. It ruined his own holidays during peak periods.
• Cleaning is Everything: Guests have a higher expectation and most expect “a hotel even though it’s not.” Any lapse in cleaning standards leads to compensation and complaints.
• Location is King: Features like a pool, proximity to the beach, or a separate self-contained area for two families make an asset stand out and justify much higher peak prices.
• Accessibility Matters: If you plan to manage it yourself, being able to drive to the property quickly is vital. This allows you to resolve issues faster and enjoy the asset yourself more easily.
Maximising your yield when purchasing property in Australia
The promise of higher income from a holiday rental often blinds investors to the true costs. Before committing to purchasing property in australia for short-term letting, you must run the numbers correctly.
Running the numbers on short-term rentals
Short-term letting carries higher costs (cleaning, linen, utilities, maintenance) than a long-term tenancy.
• Net Yield Focus: You must properly calculate the net yield after all expenses, especially with new regulations and land taxes in certain states.
• Tax Considerations: New land tax changes are a “big shift in circumstance” for many landlords. People need to run the numbers and assess what sort of income returns, after all costs, they will actually be getting.
• Justifying High Rates: People expect everything to be working if they are paying a premium rate. Your property must meet the standard required to justify charging a high rate during peak times.
Long-term wealth: Strategic principles for purchasing property in Australia
Even when buying specifically for short-term rental income, the fundamentals of strategic, long-term asset selection are essential for capital growth.
Prioritising land for capital growth
Josh’s first purchase, a three-bedroom town house in an inner northern Melbourne suburb, was a high-yielding success that paid down debt quickly. However, the true lesson was gained in hindsight:
• Land is the Driver: The dwelling often depreciates, but the land typically appreciates. His town house, with a small land component, missed out on the massive capital growth a larger block would have captured.
• Substance Over Cosmetics: Josh advises that he likely should have gone for a run-down house on a larger piece of land. This insight changed his strategy for later purchases, where he prioritised the block size over the property’s initial cosmetic appeal.
Mastering market timing and negotiation
Josh is a huge advocate for patience and preparation. He stresses that you should never rush a significant investment decision.
• Patience Wins: Always try to buy during a ‘cool patch’ in the market—when auction clearance rates are lower and activity tapers off.
• Negotiating Power: He advises seeking out private sales or properties passed in at auction. This gives you time and control to negotiate without a stressful bidding war.
• Be Ready for Opportunity: His family home was secured at a 20% discount because he was financially ready to move when the first COVID-19 lockdown froze the market. He was comfortable buying when others were panicking.
Weighing up debt, risk, and future wealth
As a financial advisor, Josh views debt strategically—it is a tool that can be leveraged, but it always comes with risk and stress.
Leveraging debt responsibly
Using debt allowed him to accelerate his wealth journey, but he cautions against over-committing:
• Compounding Assets: Josh used equity from his first purchase to help buy his second, allowing quality assets to compound on themselves.
• Risk vs. Reward: While leveraging debt has been ‘massive,’ especially when interest rates were low, it requires balance. In today’s environment, it’s critical to determine the level of risk you are personally comfortable with.
• True Costs: Always go into the process with your eyes wide open, factoring in the true costs like stamp duty, conveyancing, and furnishing costs.
Next steps: Plan your purchasing property in Australia journey
Josh’s story proves that investment success is a process built on education, patience, and clear financial planning. If you’re an investor looking to structure your first or next purchase for the Airbnb market, professional guidance can help you find your right balance of risk and reward.
Book a free consultation with Mitch
Mitch offers a free, no-obligation consultation focused on your specific property goals.
Mitch services home buyers and investors living in Melbourne, Brisbane or Sunshine Coast in Australia. Click through now to book your free call and start preparing for your next property opportunity.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: how can i balance buying a home versus an investment property?
Josh balanced this by buying a smaller, more affordable home to live in while keeping his high-yielding investment property. The home provides lifestyle; the investment provides future wealth accumulation opportunities.
Q: is it always a mistake to buy a town house or apartment?
No. Josh’s first town house generated fantastic income that helped him pay down debt quickly and build equity. The mistake was only in missing out on greater long-term capital growth. Diversification is key.
Q: how do i find an undervalued location for an airbnb?
Josh looks for locations where the lifestyle and amenities (e.g., proximity to national parks, beach, transport) do not yet match the property price point. The property itself must also have standout features, like a pool, that guests desire.